German Appellate Court Overturns Convictions of Two Rwandans Charged with War Crimes

Germany’s top appeals court has partially overturned the convictions of two Rwandan men, Ignace Murwanashyaka and his deputy Straton Musoni, who were accused of aiding and abetting war crimes in Rwanda. Their original trial, which was concluded in 2015, was a massive war crimes trial in which the Higher Regional Court in Stuttgart was in session for 320 days over a period of more than four years. The indictment, making use of the German Code of Crimes Against International Law (Völkerstrafgesetzbuch, CCAIL), which was introduced in 2002 to bring German criminal law in line with the provisions in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC), was the first major test of the principle of universal jurisdiction. While the case resulted in convictions, it also highlighted the limits of universal jurisdiction in practice. The extremely limited sentencing of these two men initially, and the subsequent overturning of major segments of their convictions, reveal the degree to which a lack of domestic resources and overwhelming international friction to a loosely defined universal jurisdiction have made current efforts, such as those in Germany, largely ineffective.